Scotty Cameron Special Select Squareback 2 Putter — An Honest 3-Month Review

The putter is the most-used club in any round. No matter how good your driver is, if you fall apart on the greens, the scorecard never recovers. In this review I break down the Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Squareback 2 after roughly three months of real-world use — covering specs, design, feel, and on-course performance. No marketing fluff; I cover the pros and cons in a balanced way.

Overview

Sole plate: the “Special Select Squareback 2” engraving and dual custom weights

The Special Select line is Scotty Cameron's redesign of the previous Select series, refining the head finish and balance even further. Within it, the Squareback 2 is a hybrid-style head that splits the difference between a blade and a mid-mallet — it keeps a blade's workability while adding a bit of forgiveness.

• Head shape: Squareback (squared rear flange) blade-style
• Material: 303 stainless steel, milled (Milled in USA)
• Neck: Plumber's neck, short slant
• Toe hang: Yes — suited to an arc stroke
• Alignment: Single sight line + 3 dots

Design & Finish Quality

Face: the tight milling pattern that grabs the ball and stabilizes the initial roll

The sole plate features symmetrically placed custom weights. These tune the head's weight distribution and swing balance, and the "Special Select Squareback 2" engraving and crown logo are cut with precision. Even the finish around the screw fittings is uniform, showcasing the quality of the milling process.

The face has a tight milling pattern. This isn't merely cosmetic — it's a functional design that grabs the ball at impact to stabilize the initial roll. In practice, the sense that the ball starts straight without skidding comes directly from this milling.

Overall finish quality is this putter's single greatest strength. Its presence in the bag and the visual satisfaction at address rank among the best in its class.

Alignment System

Top view: a single sight line and three dots keep alignment simple

The top line carries a single sight line and three dots. Unlike many recent mallet putters that adopt busy alignment aids, this model simplifies target-line alignment with a minimal single line. Because your eyes converge on one reference, it's easy to achieve consistency in aim during setup. If you're a player who draws an alignment line on the ball, the fit is especially good.

On-Course Performance

At address over a ball during 3–4m drills on the indoor putting mat

Over about three months I used it mainly for repeated 3–4m drills on an indoor putting mat, while also putting it into play during actual rounds.

Feel
The solid feedback typical of stainless steel is clear. It's not overly soft, yet a smooth sensation transfers to the fingertips at impact. The sound is crisp and consistent, which serves as an auditory aid for distance control.

Distance control
There's enough head weight to reduce wrist involvement and encourage a shoulder-driven pendulum stroke. For the first two weeks or so the ball tended to run past the hole, but after adjusting, distance became consistent even with a short backswing, and lag-putt distance control settled down.

Alignment & direction
Thanks to the single sight line, aim was highly repeatable, and confidence on short putts improved noticeably. By my own records, average putts per round dropped from 34–36 to around 31–32. I can't attribute that to the putter alone, but it clearly contributed to short-game stability.

Drawbacks & Considerations

1. Value for money: The absolute price is high. On performance alone the cost efficiency is low; brand value and collectibility make up a large share of the price.
2. Finish durability: The finish is excellent but sensitive to scratches. Micro-scratches appear with real use, so a headcover is essential.
3. Stroke fit: Because of the toe hang, the head is optimized for an arc stroke rather than a straight-back-straight-through stroke. Before buying, confirm compatibility with your own stroke through a fitting or test roll.

Verdict

Recommended for

• Players with an arc stroke
• Players who value blade-style workability and collectibility
• Players who prefer a simple alignment system

Not recommended for

• Players who prioritize pure value for money
• Beginners who need high forgiveness on mishits

The Squareback 2 isn't a club that dramatically transforms your score; rather, it raises the completeness of your putting routine through setup consistency and psychological confidence. Given that golf is ultimately a mental game, the practical value of that confidence is far from trivial.

Overall rating: ★★★★☆ (4.5 / 5) — the half-point deduction is entirely down to price.

This review is based on a personal experience of buying the putter myself and using it for three months. Feel and performance can vary with your own stroke style, so please treat it as a reference. Feel free to leave questions in the comments.